Court dates announced to deal with Maryland congressional and legislative redistricting maps

Newly proposed Maryland Congressional Maps that will be decided in court

I am having a bad feeling that it is getting less and less likely that the new candidate filing deadline of March 22nd will hold in Maryland. Here is information from a press release from Judicial Watch on March 8th:

Judicial Watch: Trial Set March 15 for Lawsuit Challenging Maryland’s Gerrymandering Abuse

Judicial Watch announced today that a Maryland court has set a trial date for its lawsuit against the State of Maryland that challenges the state’s 2021 Congressional redistricting plan. In moving forward with the case, the court denied the motion of the State of Maryland and its election officials to dismiss Judicial Watch’s lawsuit against them.  The trial is scheduled for March 15-18, 2022.

Judicial Watch filed the lawsuit on behalf of 12 registered Maryland voters who object to Maryland’s 2021 congressional redistricting plan on the grounds that it is a partisan gerrymander that diminishes their rights to participate in free and fair elections for the U.S. Congress on an equal basis with other Maryland voters, in violation of the Maryland Constitution (Parrott et al. v Lamone et al. (No. C-02-CV-21-001773)).  The trial will also include plaintiffs from a separate lawsuit against the Maryland gerrymander.

Judicial Watch’s lawsuit details:

Maryland’s recent history of partisan gerrymandering is no secret. [its 2011] congressional district map … remains one of the most notorious partisan gerrymanders in U.S. history. A federal district judge openly doubted that it could provide “fair and effective representation for all citizens.”  Another called it “absurd” to suggest ‘that there is a community of interest” in a district described as a “Rorschach-like eyesore.” [A federal appeals court] famously described the same district as “a broken-winged pterodactyl, lying prostrate across the center of the state.”

The lawsuit relates that a bipartisan commission recommended a map to Maryland Governor Larry Hogan on November 5 that he approved, but the legislature passed a different proposal in a straight party-line vote. On December 9, 2021, Hogan vetoed this proposal, and, the same day, the state legislature overrode his veto on another party-line vote.

Outside experts agree that the plan is flawed, with the nonpartisan Princeton Gerrymandering Project giving it a grade of “F” for fairness and geographic compactness. In 2020, Republicans accounted for approximately 35% of Maryland’s congressional votes, but they’re unlikely to win even a single seat under this plan. This outcome wouldn’t be possible without political gerrymandering.

“This historic challenge and trial are necessary because Democrats in the legislature abused power in setting up Maryland’s gerrymandered congressional maps,” stated Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton. “This trial is about protecting the rights of all voters and citizens. Politicians shouldn’t get to pick their voters.”

In June 2015, Judicial Watch filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Maryland’s gerrymandered congressional district map in federal court. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of voters in each of Maryland’s congressional districts—including Maryland Delegate Neil Parrott, who is also the lead plaintiff in this new state-court lawsuit. In December 2016, Judicial Watch filed a brief in the U.S. Supreme Court in response to Maryland’s attempt to retain the gerrymandered voter districting plan.

Judicial Watch is being assisted by Gardner M. Duvall of Whiteford Taylor Preston in Baltimore, and by William J. Holtzinger, Esq., of Frederick, Maryland.


So we now wait for that lawsuit to complete and see what happens. The upside is that the trial is expected to end on March 18th.

Here is the problem…the trial for the new Maryland Legislative Districts begins on March 22nd:

Trial to begin for 2022 Legislative Districting of the State

  • WHAT: Trial for In the Matter of 2022 Legislative Districting of the State
  • WHEN: Tuesday, March 22 at 10 a.m.

See the media advisory from March 8th here:

The proceeding will take place at the Court of Appeals in Annapolis and will be broadcast live online.

According to The Daily Record “Court of Appeals Chief Judge Joseph Getty consolidated the challenges, which have already led to revised 2022 candidate filing deadlines. A state elections official said last month that the ongoing litigation could also force a delay of the June 28 primary.

Wilner has indicated in court filings that he intends to file his report with the Court of Appeals on April 5.

Read the full article here:


So if Special Magistrate Alan M. Wilner does not file his report until April 5th that would seem to indicate another upcoming delay (I would expect) in the candidate filing deadline….and maybe even a delay in the Primary date (depending on the ruling).

The State Board of Elections still lists March 22nd as the current filing deadline as of this morning:

I will watch for and report out updates here on the Blog.

As for the Blog…I had already extended operations to March 23rd based on the last extension of the candidate filing deadline. I am not sure what this will mean for me and this entity going forward. I will have more details on that in the coming week.

Scott E

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s